Pick Your Poison


    • + Earn 44 Reward points
Share on pinterest


Pick Your Poison is the “Would you rather…?” party game where you can find out which of your friends are the most messed up.

There’s 350 Poison Cards, including:

  • Fart every time you kiss someone.
  • Try as hard as you can to hold every handshake for 30 seconds.
  • Live without music.
  • Be required to steal from every tip jar you see.

Player Testimonials:

  • “This was the most popular group game at game night.”
  • “This card game is hilarious… I couldn’t believe my friends choices”
  • “Cards Against Humanity + Would You Rather = So much fun”


Each Round one player is the Judge. The Judge combines two Poison cards creating a really hard “would you rather…?” scenario.

Players then ask questions about the Poison cards and the Judge expands on them as they wish.
Players anonymously “Pick their poison” and hope the other players agree with them.

Votes are revealed and points are tallied by the Judge. The Judge wins when players disagree, players win when they vote with the majority of other players.


  • Game Board
  • 350 Poison Cards
  • Pick and Double Down cards for 16 players
  • Score Sheet


Shipping Details

Order by 1pm weekdays & your order will be delivered:

  • Urgent: Next day
  • Standard: 2-3 weekdays
  • Rural: 3-5 weekdays
  • International: 3-10 weekdays

Product Information

  • UPC: 856732007004


Ask a Question

No Questions at the moment Log in or Sign Up to be the first to ask.

Customer Reviews

Write Your Own Review

You're reviewing: Pick Your Poison

How do you rate this product?*
  1 star 2 stars 3 stars 4 stars 5 stars

Please Sign up or Login to ask a question